|
Post by ciathug on Feb 21, 2014 23:07:20 GMT -5
I am not convinced this is a hoax at all. It may have false info mixed in by disinfo. But we can see the LM interior, and the EBE, as well as outside the LM _ The Mission patch is also on the LM interior.
I am convinced there is truth to all this. But it does seem partially contaminated by disinfo. The "powers that be" would not want this info out, so they do what they can to make it look like a hoax.
|
|
|
Post by hitman on Feb 21, 2014 23:10:52 GMT -5
The mission patch doesn't hold up very well as proof. I can get a unit patch showing that I'm a member of GI Joe, or the 8th Cadian Imperial Guard. I can get full-up 6' banners to show that I'm a member of the Dark Angels chapter of the Space Marines (what ever gave you the idea that I play Warhammer 40K? ).
My biggest problems with the whole "Apollo 20" story are ones I've mentioned elsewhere, and I'm still waiting to see them addressed.
1) What happened to Apollo 18? I watched Apollo 17, and supporters of this story claim to have evidence of Apollo 19 and 20. That leaves a not exactly small missing item...an entire Apollo mission.
2) Where did the launch vehicles come from? Saturn V rockets aren't small, in any sense of the word. Fabricating the stages was a huge industrial effort, carried out by multiple contractors in multiple states. Unfortunately for the Apollo 20 story, all of the Saturn Vs are accounted for. Where did the two extras come from? It's not like we could have accidentally slipped in a few extras in the middle of a long production run.
3) How were the stages transported and assembled without anyone knowing? Specialized barges and nearly unique aircraft were used for the "known" Saturn Vs. Those assets weren't available for these 'clandestine' launches.
4) How were 3 Saturn Vs (Apollo 18,19, and 20) launched with nobody noticing? Preparing a Saturn for launch was a 40+ hour process that required unique (and huge) buildings and equipment, several dozen technicians on the pad, and a firing team of around 100. Communications with a lunar mission required thousands of people in a network that panned the globe (not all of it US territory, and all of it vulnerable to intercept by non-US installations)...Saturn V launches were visible for scores of miles in daytime, and would have been more so at night. Somehow, *none* of this activity got noticed by anybody who wasn't part of the cover up?
It just doesn't strike me as possible, never mind reasonable.
|
|
|
Post by spygirl on Feb 21, 2014 23:15:34 GMT -5
I believe "they" are, and have, sent up secret missions into space many times. Maybe they do it from secret locations. Just imagine all the satellites going up. I am not an expert, but they could be launching a secret manned mission to Mars right now, and I would never know.
But sure, anyone can make a patch, but I think no one has shown the interior of the LM to be fake, and the patch and USA/USSR flag is shown in the LM interior, as well as the film inside that shows the USA and USSR rover out the LM window, as well as a large artificial structure(part of the city?) on the top left hill.
|
|
|
Post by spion on Feb 21, 2014 23:26:13 GMT -5
There's a difference between launching a secret *payload* into orbit...which happens fairly frequently, and a secret launch (one that's totally unknown by the public). Even a relatively small (compared to a Saturn V) and common launch (something like a Delta, perhaps) will be a very noticed event. The launch itself will be visible (and audible) for literally miles, and the exhaust plume as the rocket climbs will be even more visible...not only from miles away on the ground, but to airline pilots and passengers and civil aviators over most of a state or two.
Air traffic controllers will know about it too...either because the FAA will notify them in advance (the usual method) or because of the sudden flurry of "What was THAT?!" traffic from the aforementioned pilots (in the event of some secret launch).
It's also far from trivial to hide a launch site. Too many very large buildings and fairly distinctive support structures are needed to ship / assemble / preflight / fuel / launch a large rocket.
As for showing the interior of the LM to be fake, I could counter-argue (if I were so inclined) that no one has shown it to be legitimate, either...but that wouldn't really be a productive approach. I'll also confess that I'm having trouble finding decent video or still shots...a lot of the links I hit with a search are broken, or the videos have been removed. Based on what I have been able to see, the LM seems remarkably spacious (there seems to be room for two astronauts and an alien corpse (based on our experience with putting three astronauts in the LM for a return to Earth on the Apollo 13 mission, I'd say that might be doable, if uncomfortable for various reasons), and room to do a certain amount of poking and prodding at the most significant historical find in human history (which seems like a really bad idea, from a scientific point of view). The LM also seems remarkably well lit, compared to images from other Apollo flights As a sort of a late addendum...I've asked before where we got the spare Saturn Vs to launch these secret moon missions. I could add the LM to the list of "where did we get it?" items. It's not like we made hundreds of LMs, It might be easy to slip an extra item into a production run of several hundred...but in a production run of 20-30, one extra item (particularly a big-ticket item like a Saturn stage or a LM) is going to stand out a bit.
|
|
|
Post by agentmulder on Feb 21, 2014 23:31:22 GMT -5
I take most of your points, but not every 'launch' is that obvious; unless you can tell me when these launched;
eol.jsc.nasa.gov... eol.jsc.nasa.gov...
|
|
|
Post by Apollo_18 on Feb 21, 2014 23:34:55 GMT -5
ok - a few std suestions i would like the " commander " to address
1 where were the components of the ` apollo 19 ` built ?
2 how were they transported to the lauch site ?
3 how were they assembled ?
4 what was the exact time / date of lift off ?
|
|
|
Post by ispyi on Feb 21, 2014 23:37:28 GMT -5
Very interesting to read. It would be easy to discard this as a hoax though.
And if it is that, it would be great script for a sci-fi movie, someone would make money on it... If it actually happened, it would be a real "world turner"
|
|
|
Post by voltaire on Feb 22, 2014 3:19:42 GMT -5
My first reaction is that I have some reservations regarding the identity of the man. This is not about technical details, but simply the way he expresses himself.
To explain what I mean, I will quote your own statement:
I am not so sure I agree with you that is someone who knows english very well. I think his english is rather awkward:
I don't believe this was written by someone who has english/american as his first language. What are your thoughts about this? I understand that you as a journalist are protecting his identity, but have you done research based on his name, and if so, have you been able to find any kind of information that confirms this person's identity?
|
|
|
Post by paranormalskits on Feb 22, 2014 3:27:01 GMT -5
Can you tell me is William Rutledge alright? I have been worried for a while now that he was harmed in some way for sharing his account of Apollo 20.
From the very start when he first started posting on youtube, I've been searching for more and more information, i heard an interview with him over a year ago now, he expressed in the interview how worried he had become for his own safety, I'm not certain but i think he was living on the African Continent at the time.
I've never had to justify my belief that part of this story was true, seeing how it fitted with some information that was told to me several years before, since then i have followed the story with a lot of interest, and have not been disappointed at all.
The only time that a doubt crossed my mind was when it became apparent there was a disinformation campaign being carried out maybe 8 months or so ago, i did try and contact William Rutledge to see if he was alright, but heard nothing at all from him which got me very worried, and not just for him, but for the whole story.
I am not saying i believe everything that has been told so far, but i know for sure part of it is. When will part 2 of this interview be posted? also do you have a link to any unreleased video?
My personal belief is that this story can not be allowed to just vanish, and it looks like people like you are working to bring the truth to light, keep up the good work, and don't let those who wish for it to disappear push you out of the way.
|
|
|
Post by judgementday on Feb 22, 2014 3:34:31 GMT -5
Dang! I JUST saw this as a video while looking for other things on the net over the weekend. I Cannot remember for the life of me where!!! I figured it was already on the site and if I started a thread it would go away.
|
|